Super Micro Computer (SMCI) has been on a rollercoaster ride over the past two years. The stock soared 730% from May 2023 to March 2024—only to plunge nearly 85% to a November 2024 low. Since then, shares have more than doubled and returned to earth thereafter. For every record-high SMCI has set, there is a record plunge and a record low just around the corner. Joining the deep-value party at this stage might be a case of too little, too late.
Discover the Best Stocks and Maximize Your Portfolio:
- See what stocks are receiving strong buy ratings from top-rated analysts.
- Filter, analyze, and streamline your search for investment opportunities with TipRanks’ Stock Screener.
With a giddy 1,323% share price increase over the past three years under SMCI’s belt, there is trouble ahead for SMCI speculators and long-term investors alike. Wall Street analysts are also skeptical, expecting 2025 to be a tumultuous year for SMCI for all the wrong reasons.
In such exuberant times, savvy investors will stay cool even as super-hot AI stocks like SMCI blaze hotter (and higher). I remain neutral with a bearish bias on SMCI since much of its growth hinges on ambitious forward guidance that is overly optimistic at current metrics.
Super Micro’s AI Surge Amid Big Tech Shifts
Between 2023 and 2024, Super Micro’s products surged in popularity as the AI revolution gathered steam. The $33 billion capped server manufacturer offers multiple products, including MP servers, GPUs, and its proprietary platform, MicroCloud. Offering the right products at the right time helped the company achieve an impressive 110% year-over-year revenue increase in FY2024. Yet, major data center developers are increasingly bypassing traditional server builders like Super Micro.
Giants such as Amazon (AMZN), Google (GOOGL), and Microsoft (MSFT) are designing custom servers optimized for Nvidia (NVDA) GPUs, often opting for cost-effective, tailor-made solutions sourced from Original Design Manufacturers (ODMs) in Asia. This trend renders Super Micro’s off-the-shelf offerings less attractive for big tech’s AI aspirations and future endeavors.
On the bright side, the emergence of DeepSeek‑R1—a cost-efficient AI model from China—suggests that AI development could soon become accessible to a much broader array of companies. As new entrants scramble for computing infrastructure (without the means to build bespoke solutions), demand for readily available servers might surge—a potential bullish catalyst for Super Micro.
SMCI Potential Meets Market Risk
It’s important to note that Super Micro has long battled accounting issues. Given these concerns, I’m not rushing to invest in Super Micro. In the competitive AI space, I lean towards companies like Nvidia, ASML (ASML), and Advanced Micro Devices (AMD)—firms that combine robust growth prospects with enduring competitive moats and pristine regulatory records.
With a price-to-earnings (P/E) ratio of 24.1 and an expected three-year annual EPS growth rate of 22.9%, SMCI appears to be valued fairly relative to industry norms. There is room for upside if the company hits its bold 2026 revenue target of $40 billion—significantly above the consensus of $33 billion. However, this optimistic scenario is a double-edged sword: a bull run could follow if targets are met, but missing them might open the door for bears to take control.
Competition Remains Super Micro’s Achilles Heel
Super Micro has already lost key clients due to quality and service issues. For example, CoreWeave—once its largest customer—has shifted to Dell (DELL) for its GPU servers. Similarly, Tesla (TSLA) has diversified its supplier base to include Dell. Meanwhile, Hewlett Packard Enterprise (HPE) is also aggressively expanding and stifling SMCI’s metrics. SMCI seems to have been caught in a pincer movement with multiple competitors offering multiple high-value offerings in multiple market segments simultaneously.
Dell, in particular, stands out with its remarkable track record and Michael Dell’s visionary leadership. With its AI Factory division offering a broad range of AI solutions and an infrastructure solutions business unit that posted a 34% year-over-year revenue jump in Q3 2025, Dell’s momentum could leave Super Micro trailing.
Mounting reputational concerns will likely fuel negative sentiment among customers and investors, reinforcing my decision to stay off the SMCI bull trail.
Why SMCI Bulls Love the Stock
While I prefer to stay on the sidelines regarding SMCI stock due to various risk factors, some see it differently. Considering the opposing bullish case is essential to maintain as much objectivity as possible. SMCI bulls seem enamored by its lower valuation multiples compared to historical highs.
For example, at its 2024 peak, the company’s P/E ratio exceeded 80. Now that it has eased to around 25, many believe they’re snagging a bargain. However, this isn’t the complete picture—growth rates have also moderated. Over the past 12 months, Super Micro achieved a 110% revenue growth rate, yet its forward revenue growth is now projected at just 67%.
This real-terms growth deceleration will persist unless management surprises us with its ambitious $40 billion revenue projection for FY26. Even Wedbush—a renowned tech-centric Wall Street firm—expects Super Micro to deliver only $35 billion in revenue for FY2026.
Is SMCI Stock a Good Buy?
According to Wall St. analysts, SMCI stock carries a Hold consensus rating based on three Buy, two Hold, and two Sell ratings over the past three months. SMCI’s average price target of $36.50 per share implies a brutal 34.6% potential downside over the coming twelve months. Having just recently reiterated his Sell rating on SMCI, leading analyst Samik Chatterjee from J.P. Morgan is targeting SMCI stock to fall to around $23-35 this year. Ultra-bear Mehdi Hosseini from Susquehanna sees the stock trading at ~$15 per share later this year.
Wall Street’s negative sentiment mirrors my own cautious outlook, driven by valuation concerns, regulatory issues, and fierce competitive pressures.
AI Stocks Are Hot, But Smart Investors Stay Cool
While the hype around hot AI stocks is undeniable, the most successful investors maintain a disciplined approach and avoid chasing the hottest trends without deep fundamental analysis. What goes up tends to come down eventually. In SMCI’s case, Wall St. has made its verdict, with most analysts expecting bullish fatigue to set in this year.
Emphasizing value remains a prudent strategy for long-term success. Although SMCI might offer some short-term speculative upside, its volatile nature makes it a bumpy ride for those seeking stable investments with reliable returns.
