I’m embarrassed to say I never gave GameStop (GME) stock a second look when Roaring Kitty sent the stock surging on two occasions earlier this year. However, on closer inspection, there’s more to the company than I had expected. It’s sitting on strong cash reserves and has very little long-term debt. Nonetheless, I’m bearish because the valuation is simply stretched, given the company’s earnings potential. Moreover, I can’t see a significant turnaround on the horizon.
Pick the best stocks and maximize your portfolio:
- Discover top-rated stocks from highly ranked analysts with Analyst Top Stocks!
- Easily identify outperforming stocks and invest smarter with Top Smart Score Stocks
GameStop and Roaring Kitty
Let’s start by reminding ourselves why GameStop stock is so well known. The video game retailer, headquartered in Grapevine, Texas, became a global phenomenon during the 2021 short squeeze. Retail investors on Reddit, inspired by “Roaring Kitty” (Keith Gill), drove the stock price from $17.25 to over $500, challenging Wall Street hedge funds.
At the time, the company was struggling with declining physical game sales while the pandemic shifted the firm’s sales online — for the full year 2020, the average share of online sales stood at 30%, compared to 5% in 2019. Nonetheless, it remained a business in trouble, suffering from slowing foot traffic, increasing competition from digital game downloads, and an overall shift in consumer behavior away from physical media.
GameStop Has Benefitted from the Meme Trade
Since 2021, GameStop has indeed benefited significantly from the meme stock phenomenon, primarily through increased interest from retail investors and a substantial cash infusion.
The surge in its stock price allowed the company to capitalize on its newfound popularity, raising over $1.1 billion through a stock offering in June 2021, followed by another $400 million in September 2023. This influx of capital boosted GameStop’s cash reserves to approximately $4.2 billion by July 31, 2024, marking a 251.9% increase year-over-year.
Additionally, the company used some of these funds to pay down its long-term debt, which was reduced to just $17.7 million as of February 3, 2024. Consequently, it’s fair to say that GameStop is a company with sound financials. With a net cash position of $3.86 billion, the firm could theoretically generate more than $100 million annually in net interest income. However, I remain bearish because the company’s earnings forecast really isn’t very strong, and the business continues to bounce around its breakeven point.
Valuation Remains Stretched
Adding to my negative outlook is GME’s stretched valuation. The stock is currently trading at 212x its trailing 12-month (TTM) earnings and 529x forward earnings. This forward metric is a 2,608% premium to the consumer discretionary sector average. Moreover, the earnings forecast is very sketchy, with no clear improvements in earnings throughout the medium term.
Even taking into account the company’s cash reserves, the business looks expensive. On a TTM basis, the stock’s EV-to-EBITDA ratio is 172x — that’s a 1,366% premium to the sector average. Clearly, the stock is still overvalued.
GameStop Is Transforming, but not Enough for Me
Additionally, management’s transformation and diversification plan aren’t enough to justify the valuation. Nonetheless, I recognize that GameStop’s recent partnership with Professional Sports Authenticator (PSA) marks a significant step in the company’s efforts to diversify its business model and attract new customers. As an authorized PSA dealer, GameStop will now offer authentication and grading services for trading cards at some stores across the U.S.
This initiative follows GameStop’s earlier move into purchasing high-grade Pokémon cards, reflecting a strategic shift toward the collectibles market. Customers will now be able to drop off their cards at participating GameStop locations, with the company handling the entire grading process from submission to shipping.
GameStop is also leveraging its online platform to expand into buying and selling graded sports and TCG cards. To generate buzz, the company has even offered bounties for rare cards, such as a $25,000 reward for a specific 2024 Panini Lionel Messi card. These initiatives not only create a new revenue stream but also aim to increase foot traffic in stores and create new touchpoints for engagement. Still, it’s not enough to justify the huge valuation multiples.
Is GameStop Corp Stock a Buy According to Analysts?
On TipRanks, GME comes in as a Moderate Sell based on one Sell rating assigned in the past three months. Wedbush’s Michael Pachter is the lone analyst covering GME stock with a price target of $10, implying about 62.4% downside risk.
The Bottom Line on GameStop Stock
While GameStop Corp has significantly improved its financial position, particularly through the capital raised during the meme stock phenomenon, the company’s overall valuation remains a concern. With strong cash reserves and minimal long-term debt, GameStop is in a better place than before; however, its earnings potential does not justify the current stock price. Moreover, I’m not convinced that management’s PSA move will do much to move the needle.
Ultimately, it’s not a stock I will consider buying. However, it’s certainly an interesting stock to keep an eye on, given its volatility in recent years.
